Audrey first appears in the episode "Welcome to Bushwick a.k.a. The Crackcident, where Marnie learns that her ex-boyfriend Charlie is dating her only two weeks since they broke up. She works as a blogger, and has a popular website. She and Charlie travel to Europe together while she's working on a photography job, and posts several romantic pictures of them online.
Audrey is still dating Charlie, and the two attend Hannah and Elijah's housewarming party in It's About Time. She then begins to feel insecure in their relationship after Marnie spends the night at Charlie's place. She confronts Marnie during a dinner thrown by Hannah in "It's a shame about Ray" about her inappropriate behavior, which causes Marnie to leave and go the roof. When Charlie follows her, Audrey then leaves and ends their relationship.